THB #555: What Inside Out 2's Numbers Don't Mean
This morning (it’s 9am pacific as I type), Deadline and Penske outlet The Hollywood Reporter are projecting the Inside Out 2 opening at $155 million domestic. Variety hasn’t bothered updating since its “reporting” on Friday’s gross yesterday morning.
Please note, as ever, that $40 million or 26% of the domestic gross for the weekend has not happened as these estimates for the entire weekend are “reported” like facts.
Please also note that the trade coverage has been wrong at every step of this opening, though they are arguing that they had it right in their Saturday night reporting, even though they really have no way of knowing because Sunday’s moviegoing hasn’t happened yet.
On Tuesday of last week, Deadline reported that Inside Out 2 would have a $85 million opening weekend.
On Thursday, The Hollywood Reporter slotted the opening in at $85 million - $90 million.
On Friday, Deadline wrote about a “potential $100M+” opening weekend.
By Friday Afternoon, Deadline was estimating a $120m - $130m weekend.
On Saturday morning, Deadline was sure that Inside Out 2 would do. remarkable $140m - $150m.
By Saturday evening, that number became $150m - $155m.
As of this morning, The Penskes are sticking with $155 million, still misleading with “the tentpole opened to…” and Inside Out 2 is coming in at…”
They don’t know. Maybe they will be right. Maybe it will be higher. Maybe it will be lower. These are guesses.
I have been covering box office professionally for almost 30 years now - going back to the days of phones, typing out reports, and faxing them - and the reality remains the same. A handful of people are telling the media what to write every step of the way. The actual numbers being gathered have become a bit more sophisticated and fast. It’s harder to cheat. But it’s all still a statistical analysis, projected and read differently by a handful of companies, who then try to convince The Penskes to write it up how they prefer… whether that is overestimating by competitors or low-balling by the releasing distributors.
The smaller the real numbers, the less anyone notices the (often intentional) mistakes. Tracking remains often problematic when it comes to family movies, horror movies, and movies with a high proportion of people of color interested/attending. And as I am often reminded, the public claims of “what tracking is” on any given movie is twisted by politicking between the distributors and the analytics companies whose claims are published by the trades… and repeated endlessly as gospel by every other outlet.
It doesn’t really matter in any way, shape or form whether Deadline has an accurate box office number mid-week or Friday or Saturday or even Sunday… except as publicity that is then repeated across the globe. And so, it is treated as publicity, not business.
My point is not to beat up Anthony and Deadline’s many weekly advertorial sponsors of box office bullshit, like Comscore/Screen Engine’s PostTrak, which seems to be making a push to eclipse the nearly-worthless CinemaScore, and of course, RelishMix, which lives up to its name by adding a lot of flavor that really has no effect on the hot dog itself.
Don’t get me wrong, these analytic companies can be of great value to the distributors, especially on hit films that are going to continue getting support by their distributors after the first weekend. That is why they exist. But on the pages of Deadline, the quotes and blase’ suggesting that what is being quoted means anything is silly, at best.
For example…
“Social media reach for Inside Out 2 across TikTok, X, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube stands at 556.4M which is ahead of Kung Fu Panda 4 (353.5M) and Trolls Bands Together (287M), but below Minions: The Rise of Gru (668.4M). Stranger Things actress Maya Hawke, who voices the new character of Anxiety, is leading the charge among the voiceover cast on social with a reach of 10M-plus.
One notable clip that racked up views on YouTube was the “Booth to Screen” of the voiceover cast:
Are you fucking kidding me with that?
It got fewer than a million views… which is great, actually. But does anyone actually believe those views have ANYTHING to do with the box office this weekend? Or should I say, “anything more than .001% of the box office?” (That’s about 150 tickets.)
I would be more than happy for the trades to do special reports on hit films and all the tools they used towards the end of building those hits. But it doesn’t belong in the box office reporting. And if you took the failures and did similar reports, you would find a varied, but nearly identical set of efforts make for flops with similar marketing spends.
Here is the “FURIOSA : A MAD MAX SAGA | Motorbike Messiah Featurette” that got 413k views vs the “Inside Out 2 | Booth To Screen” feature that got 868k views.
Naturally then, Furiosa opened to a little less than half of what Inside Out 2 opened to, right? Nope. One-sixth.
As Ennui might say, “Le duh.”
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Hot Button to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.